Ethics
Publication Ethics
The Journal is firmly committed to upholding international standards of publication ethics, strictly adhering to the guidelines set forth by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to ensure the accuracy, transparency, and credibility of all published research. Authors, reviewers, and editors must strictly comply with the following ethical principles:
Duties of Editors
-
Publication Decisions: The Editor-in-Chief/Editorial Board is responsible for deciding which articles submitted to the journal should be accepted or rejected. These decisions are based solely on the academic merit, methodological rigor, validity of results, significance of the study, and originality of the work.
-
Fair Play and Transparency: The Editor-in-Chief/Editorial Board selects manuscripts for publication after the completion of the peer review process. Decisions are guided by academic rationale, significance, novelty, clarity of content, and relevance to the journal’s scope and objectives, without bias or discrimination against the authors.
-
Confidentiality: Editors must maintain strict confidentiality regarding all submitted manuscripts under review. They must not disclose any information about a manuscript to anyone other than those involved in the evaluation process, and must protect the personal data of authors, reviewers, and other related parties throughout the review process.
-
Conflicts of Interest: Editors must have no conflicts of interest regarding the articles they consider. Furthermore, they must not use unpublished materials or information disclosed in a submitted manuscript for their own personal advantage or research.
-
Pre-publication Screening: Editors must systematically screen all manuscripts prior to publication to detect duplicate publication, redundant submission, and plagiarism.
-
Correction and Retraction: Editors must establish and maintain a system for correcting major errors or retractions when a published article is found to have violated research ethics. They must not ignore or neglect any reported misconduct or ethical breaches related to published work.
Duties of Reviewers
-
Contribution and Expertise: Reviewers should only accept manuscripts within their field of expertise. They are responsible for evaluating the significance of the manuscript to the field based on academic reasoning, novelty, clarity, and overall quality, while providing objective and unbiased feedback.
-
Promptness and Timeliness: Reviewers must complete their evaluation within the specified timeframe. If they are unable to review the manuscript or complete it on time, they must notify the editor immediately so that an alternative reviewer can be assigned.
-
Confidentiality: Reviewers must treat all manuscripts received for review as confidential documents. They must not disclose any information or contents of the manuscript to unauthorized parties, nor use any data, concepts, or innovations from the manuscript for personal gain.
-
Conflicts of Interest: Reviewers must have no conflicts of interest with the authors. If a reviewer identifies a potential conflict of interest, they must notify the editor and decline the review invitation immediately.
-
Reporting Misconduct: If a reviewer identifies any substantial similarity or overlap between the manuscript under consideration and any other published work, they must promptly inform the editor.
Duties of Authors
-
Academic Integrity: Manuscripts submitted for publication must possess academic value and contribute to future education and research. Authors must report their findings accurately and must not fabricate, falsify, or manipulate research data.
-
Originality: Submitted manuscripts must be entirely original work that has not been previously published elsewhere and is not currently under consideration for publication by any other journal or academic medium.
-
Compliance with Guidelines: Authors must format and prepare their manuscripts strictly in accordance with the journal’s "Author Guidelines."
-
Plagiarism Prevention: Submitted works must be completely free of plagiarism. Authors must not copy, paraphrase, or truncate research from others without proper acknowledgment or citation.
-
Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest: Authors must explicitly declare any potential conflicts of interest (if any) that could be perceived to influence the results or interpretation of their manuscript.